I thought I would never see a
down fall of a well establish brand and it will remain only in our marketing
books that every product has a life cycle.
For those who have no idea
about the product life cycle, it is one of the core principles of marketing
that every product goes through 4 stages
1:Introduction
2:Growth
3:Maturity
4: Decline
2:Growth
3:Maturity
4: Decline
When my marketing teacher
introduced this concept, it suddenly came to my mind that only newly opened
businesses can decline as one can understand that it is hard for them to sustain but
once the product reaches its peak how can it decline. Or else not very huge
companies can decline like Frooto, Choco Chums, Haleeb, RC Cola and Polka to
name a few but their decline was primarily because of the tough competition
from the huge companies like Nestlé Unilever Coca Cola and Pepsi.
Then I realized that the life
cycle exists for all the products doesn't matter if they are on their peak. Some
unbelievable declines of the recent times are Nokia, Blackberry and now GEO
which is of most interest to me being part of the same industry.
Geo has been an institution in
the Pakistan Broadcast Industry. It has produced talented journalists,
engineers, directors and many other professionals.
Things that went wrong with
geo:
1: Feeling of being super power
Geo thought they control
everything in Pakistan and to some extent it wasn’t wrong at all. However too
much of everything leads to a path where you don’t realize what you are doing.
Many think that Geo has played a vital role in defaming Pakistan
internationally. . The most disliked content ever broadcasted by geo according
to me was their attempt to proof the plan and nationality of Ajmal Kassab. I
still have a question in mind that what could be the objective of geo broadcasting
the investigating reports with no proper proofs.
I would sort of agree with it
however we should also realize the role that geo has played in promoting the
positive image of Pakistan, whether its any achievement in sports or research
or some really effective education and awareness campaigns it was only Geo in
the whole industry who could have done this for Pakistan
Although geo is by far the most
neutral content provider but one felt that something is wrong. Too much support
to the current government and being one of the biggest supporters of the
controversial Chief Justice pushed geo to where it is now. It is also said that
it is because of Geo , General Musharraf is having tough time in Pakistan. I
personally think that he doesn’t deserve what he is going through these days.
Democracy is fine, but he did what none of the democratic leadership has done
to Pakistan. He was the one who coined the free media term in Pakistan
otherwise we would be relying on the 9 pm pro government news of our state broadcaster.
2: Ignoring other participants of the race
There is another strategy that
we learnt in marketing and that is cooperative strategy. Geo didn’t consider
having alliance with any of its competitors and this lead to the grand alliance
of its competitors against geo. It is really sad when one of the journalist or team members of
any channel dies due to any terrorist activity, the other channel ignores such a
big incident. On all these occasions all the channels should have a collective
voice.
Most of the channels in Pakistan now seem to have one aim- and that is to make sure that geo doesn’t recover from
the recent hit. It should not be this way; the industry will suffer if
something happens to geo. When most of the channels are reluctant to pay even
salaries, geo has always ensured that the employee gets the salaries on time.
3: Supporting too much PML-N and ex CJ
It is a general feeling that
geo is too much pro PML N and ex CJ. No matter if geo denies this but it is
quite evident that the content after the elections has been biased. I think we
haven’t eliminated any corruption or miss management in the government run
organizations as compared to the last government but certainly we haven’t seen
that sort of criticism for this government like it was in the previous one.
4: Unnecessary defaming of ISI chief
I think this has been discussed
on all the forums so I need not to write too much on this. It shouldn’t have
happened. This is irresponsible journalism and many think that you don’t do
this with your top agency and if you do you are off air!
5: Revenge mode against Musharraf
We all know that geo was banned
in Musharraf’s reign and geo also faced tough time in UAE due to the pressure
of Gen. Musharraf however that doesn’t mean that you start taking the revenge
on air.
Things in which geo was accused
and blamed unnecessarily
1: Morning show issue & its reaction
It wasn’t an issue at all, this
was unnecessarily created by its biggest competition. I am not an expert but
this is not be wrong if I say that ARY and Mubashir Lucmans content has way
passed the level of extremely immature journalism. The series of Mubashir
Lucmans Baba ji campaign was pathetic and pointless. But it shows the mindset
of our people and how external forces creates and changes the perception of the
masses.
2: To an extent Aman ki Aasha
I think Aman Ki Aasha was a
very nice campaign if the objective was to reduce the tension at the borders
and to improve the economy. We all should realize that we should have good
relationship with our neighbours in order to excel. However at the same time if
there is some anti state activity by the neighbors then it should also be
broadcasted in order to be neutral. Certainly Aman ki Aasha is pointless if we find out that the India is
responsible for the unrest in the country. In addition to this, even if they are
responsible for this, it cannot be done with our black sheep so instead of
blaming others we should identify bad people amongst ourselves in order to
eliminate this issue.
3: Cable operators Mafia
I am sure now the government
would realize that how important for us is DTH and even if we have to continue
with the cable then they should be a proper frame work , rules and guidelines
for the cable guys to operate.
Conclusion:
I am not an expert but if geo
shuts down it will be the worst night mare of our industry. It has a huge
employee base and so many kitchens are running because of geo. Not sure how can
this be done but there should be a solution to this extremely big issue of the
industry. I wish that geo improves its deficiencies and come back on track.
With BOL to launch soon , there should be tough competition between all the
leading channels for our industry’s growth.
All the stake holders need to
realize if one horse falls in the race, the other horses also fell. So Geo should be running in order to have a smooth race!